The “Open-Shut” Case: How to Blockade a Blockade to Un-Blockade a Non-Blockade

Welcome to the 2026 Edition of Geopolitics for the Severely Concussed. If you’ve been following the news regarding the Strait of Hormuz, you might be feeling a bit of lightheadedness. Don’t worry; that’s just your brain’s natural defence mechanism trying to shut down before it has to process the tactical “genius” currently emanating from the Oval Office.

We are currently witnessing a historical first: a military operation designed to liberate a waterway by making it completely impassable. It is a blockade, to stop a blockade, that technically wasn’t a blockade, in order to prevent a future blockade. If that sentence gave you a nosebleed, congratulations – you’re officially more qualified to run Central Command than the people currently in charge.

The “Toll” of Sanity

Let’s look at the “farcical” foundations of this mess. For weeks, the Iranians were running what looked suspiciously like a very aggressive, very maritime version of a London Congestion Charge. If you wanted to sail your tanker through the Strait, you paid a “toll”. Was it legal under international law? Probably not. Was it extortion? Absolutely. Was it a blockade? No.

In fact, business was booming for everyone willing to cough up a few million quid to Tehran. It was a tax on floating objects. But President Trump, never one to let a transactional opportunity go un-insulted, decided that the best way to stop Iran from charging a toll was to park the U.S. Navy in the middle of the road and tell everyone, “If you pay the toll, we sink you. If you don’t pay the toll, they sink you. Isn’t freedom of navigation grand?”

The Logic of the “Open-Shut” Door

The stated goal is to “keep the Strait open”. However, the U.S. has achieved this by declaring a blockade on Monday at 10 a.m. sharp. Think about the physics of this for a moment. To ensure that oil can flow freely to a thirsty world, we have positioned several billion dollars’ worth of grey steel in the way to ensure that nothing flows anywhere.

It’s like finding out your front door is sticky, so you decide to “fix” it by welding it shut and then blowing up the porch. “Look,” the administration shouts over the sound of exploding sea mines, “the door is no longer sticky!”Technically true, Mr President, but we’re all currently trapped in the hallway and the house is on fire.

Economic Hara-Kiri

Then there’s the “economically suicidal” cherry on top of this madness. We are told this is a “Maximum Pressure” campaign. Usually, the pressure is supposed to be on the enemy. Instead, the pressure is being applied directly to the jugular of the global economy.

Crude oil has cleared $100 a barrel and is currently looking at $150 with the kind of hunger a wolf shows a wounded sheep. By “opening” the waterway via a blockade, the U.S. has managed to do the following:

  1. Spike the price of petrol to the point where it’s cheaper to buy a horse.
  2. Freeze global food supplies (because, it turns out, ships carry fertiliser too).
  3. Piss off every single ally we have left.

The President called the British and Spanish “cowards” and “paper tigers” for not joining this suicide pact. It’s a bold diplomatic strategy: “Hey, come help me set my own trousers on fire! No? What are you, a coward?”

The Great Geopolitical Hallucination

The most “terribly confused” part of this entire saga is the President’s belief that this will lead to a deal. He is currently on Fox News, appearing remarkably tanned and relaxed, predicting that Iran will “give us everything we want” any day now.

It’s a masterclass in lack of logic. The theory is that if we make the world’s most important maritime chokepoint a literal shooting gallery, the Iranians – who have been practising “being defiant while miserable” for forty years – will suddenly say, “Gosh, thanks for the blockade, Donald; here are the keys to our nuclear programme and a nice rug.”

In reality, the only people being “strangled” are the commuters in Ohio, the factory workers in Dusseldorf, and the logistics managers in Shanghai who are currently having collective nervous breakdowns.

Does This Help Anyone?

In a word: No.

The U.S. Navy is clearing mines just so they can sit in the spots where the mines used to be. Iran is calling it “piracy”, which is rich coming from the people charging $2 million for a “safe passage” sticker, but they aren’t wrong. The allies have backed away slowly as if encountering a man shouting at a pigeon in a park.

It is a blockade in search of a reason, a military solution to a commercial problem that has created a global catastrophe. It is the pinnacle of “doing something” just so you can say you did it, even if that “something” is the geopolitical equivalent of plugging a leaky pipe with a hand grenade.

So, as we watch the oil charts go vertical and the U.S. Navy play a high-stakes game of “Red Light, Green Light” with tankers in the Gulf, just remember the official slogan of 2026: We’re closing the ocean to make sure it stays open.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I need to go see if my bicycle can run on irony. It’s the only fuel we have left in abundance.